The Art of the Photogravure
A Comprehensive Resource Dedicated to the Photogravure
About | Site Map | Contact | Links
history process EXAMPLES resources blog search collection

March 1st, 2011

What’s Wrong With This Picture?


It is a stunning and surprisingly modern original-negative, hand-pulled, dust grained Talbot Kilc photogravure by Frank Eugene, which appeared in Stieglitz’s Camera Work 30 in 1910 – one hundred years ago.  The artist and the image are both icons in the history of photography. The image is held in the collections of the most prestigious photography museums in the world and there are fewer than 200 copies in private collections.  So how was it possible that I purchased this rare vintage print, beautifully framed, for only $250? It was not damaged, faded or in any way compromised.


The Ebay seller told me she spent over $250 to frame it.

The Ebay seller told me she spent over $250 to frame it.

The photographer, Frank Eugene (1865-1936) is regarded as one of the most significant figures of the Pictorialist movement at the turn of the century and is mentioned in almost every anthology written on the history of photography.   His revolutionary work incorporated a synthesis of painting, etching and photography and was often the subject of heated debates over weather or not a photograph should/could be ‘manipulated’ in order to achieve an artistic effect.

MK_CPOYWRK_02_11 19317


Borrowing from his experience as a painter, Eugene aggressively scratched on his negatives to remove or reduce unwanted details and to enhance the expressive characteristics of an image.

“What made Eugene so attractive not only to his contemporaries but also to Stieglitz was his totally unorthodox method

of rubbing oil onto the negatives and adding cross hatching with an etching needle sometimes leaving only small portions

of a picture recognizably photographic.” Naef  p.96

Critic Charles Caffin, who authored the landmark book Photography as a Fine Art (1901), also validated Eugene’s technique …

“only a trained and gifted photographer was in the position to create such delicate images and alter their power of

expression so masterfully by manipulating them… The print, printed as it is on Japan paper, conveys every impression

of an etching, having the beautiful characteristics that one looks for therein: spontaneousness of execution, vigorous and

pregnant suggestiveness, velvety color, and delightful evidence of the personal touch. The art is still in the womb of time,

its possibilities becoming wider and more appreciated; being new, one learns that the old standards and points of view

do not necessarily apply to it, and more and more realize the need for an open mind”


The publishers of Impressionist Camera: Pictorial Photography in Europe, 1888-1918 felt it deserving of one of the few two-page spreads in its 350 page publication.

Eugene’s unorthodox methods were controversial to say the least, and struck a nerve in the American ‘photography as art’ movement of the day amplifying the ongoing debate over weather manipulating a photograph to make it art is acceptable and justifiable.

In Eugene’s own words…

“It has often been said that the [Horse] photograph was reminiscent of an etching.  But that was in no way intended.

The banal surroundings which were inessential and disruptive to the photograph as a whole were removed from the

negative with a retouching knife, but nothing else was changed, neither the light nor the shadows, nor the form and line

of the animal’s body.”

Eugene’s aim was to suppress the inessential in favor of the essential.

Very little of Eugene’s work survives today – a typical fate of much that has to do with the history of photography and an indication of how little is known about the medium and how low esteem that part of our cultural heritage is held.

Charles Caffin obviously felt the image worthy of consideration when he used it to introduce a chapter of his landmark, "Photography as Fine Art" in 1901

If interested in this image, I will be donating it to the 2011 George Eastman House Benefit Auction and hopefully there it will command a price more in line with its pedigree.


Caffin, Charles H. Photography as a Fine Art: The Achievements and Possibilities of Photographic Art in America.  New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. 1901

Naef, Weston. The Collection of Alfred Stieglitz – Fifty Pioneers of Modern Photography. New York: The Viking Press, 1978

Pohlmann, Ulrich.  Frank Eugene: The Dream of Beauty. Munich: Nazraeli Press 1995

Prodger, Phillip. The Impressionist Camera: Pictorial Photography in Europe, 1888 – 1918.  Merrell and the Saint Louis Art Museum, 2006

9 Responses to “What’s Wrong With This Picture?”

  1. thinsmek says:

    This is very interesting to me, as an amateur photographer. I haven’t studied much about the history of photograhy, espiecially not about its role as an art form. The Horse is very bold, and I find the etching technique a new concept for me.

    Thanks for writing this article!

  2. Joel Heller says:

    Nothing is wrong. The $250 is a price that matches most other auction selling prices for his work. It all depends on the auction audience, so there must be a very small group of Frank Eugene photogravure collectors.

  3. […] Mark or scratch negatives or photos, as in this 100 year old vintage print by Frank Eugene: […]

  4. Saurabh says:

    Hi Irene!When you seal your wood canvas with Gesso you have to allow it to dry cpoeletmly. I usually do multiple ones that way they are ready to go when I’m ready to paint on them.I usually do at least 2 layers of Gesso on all sides including the back (3 layers is ideal) for longevity.Once the Gesso is dry, then you can sketch on on it.I sketch on Vellum or Tracing paper first so all the erasing and corrections are done on that and not on the wood. Once I’m happy with the drawing then I transfer it using another piece of Velum that I have rubbed cpoeletmly with a 4B pencil, you can purchase transfer paper, but I just make it my self.By transferring the drawing, you keep the Gesso clean and then begin to paint.If you do not want to deal with transferring, you can always add a layer of clear coat to the pencil sketch that is on the wood, let it dry and then start painting. The lead will be sealed and will not mix with your colors.I hope that helps.You’ve given me a nice idea for a blog post and I’ll be explaining it using pictures.Take careMaggie

  5. DragodimsDub says:

    Здравствуйте! я хочу предложить Вам прогон по качественным twitter-аккаунтам для продвижения в поисковых системах, поднятия НЧ запросов, ускорения индексации ваших сайтов, а также большое количество целевого трафика из Твиттера!


    Twitter-аккаунты: Для прогона используются отборные аккаунты, которые уже проиндексированы поисковыми системами Yandex и Google. Возраст аккаунтов от 1 года, список всегда обновляется, чтобы пользователи всегда получали лучший эффект от прогона. Каждый аккаунт имеет от 1000 подписчиков и больше.
    При заказе предоставлю примеры аккаунтов и ссылки, которые будут в отчете.
    Бэклинки: Как я писал выше, аккаунты проиндексированы поисковыми системами, тем самым стоит ожидать появление ссылок в яндекс вебмастер, а также повышение вашего сайта в выдаче поисковиков, трафик для ваших товаров и услуг.
    Результат: Наверно все уже слышали о том (а кто уже и побывал), что поисковые системы реагируют на социальные сигналы (страницы ранжируются лучше и индексируются быстрей, если они еще не проиндексированы). Одним словом, пока “тема” жива, ей нужно пользоваться, также вы получите много трафика из твиттера.

    Как заказать: от Вас нужны ссылки и анкоры к ним (обязательно, для лучшей индексации). (это могут быть ваши сайты, страницы социальных сетей, товары из интернет магазинов, различные партнерские программы и т.д)

    Если анкоров нет, мы подберем их сами. Отмечу, что около-ссылочный текст мы пишем сами, написание входит в стоимость прогона, но лучше заказывать с вашими анкорами.

    Отчет: в отчете я высылаю Вам на e-mail все ссылки на твитты.
    Стоимость услуги: 500 рублей (размещение ваших текстов и ссылок на 100 твиттер аккаунтах), принимаем оплату в Webmoney, Яндекс-деньги, Qiwi, Visa
    В Яндекс-деньги идентифицированный пользователь, в Webmoney персональный аттестат, много положительных отзывов с других сайтов и форумов. Срок выполнения менее суток.

    Контакты для заказа услуги, а также по всем интересующим вас вопросам:
    Skype: ddragodim
    Ждем ваших заказов!

  6. […] Mark or scratch negatives or photos, as in this 100 year old vintage print by Frank Eugene: […]

  7. DanaSA says:

    Требуется помощь, как вывести затертость с зеркала машины.
    Кто-то прижался во дворе и поцарапал. Деньги тратить на перекраску элемента не хочу, т.к дорого стоит.

  8. […] Mark or scratch negatives or photos, as in this 100 year old vintage print by Frank Eugene: […]

Leave a Reply